| Mirror Lake | Marion, IN | 21 miles | SW |
| Russell Lake | Boone, IN | 21.5 miles | SW |
| Lake Sullivan | Marion, IN | 26.4 miles | SW |
| Emerald Lake | Delaware, IN | 27.9 miles | NE |
| Jackson Lake | Delaware, IN | 28.3 miles | NE |
| Spring Lake | Hancock, IN | 28.9 miles | SE |
| Fox Lake | Miami, IN | 29.4 miles | NE |
| Roberts Lake | Hancock, IN | 29.6 miles | SE |
| Perry Lake | Hancock, IN | 30.4 miles | SE |
| Crane Pond | Grant, IN | 30.4 miles | NE |
| Blue Lake | Marion, IN | 31.3 miles | SW |
| Cains Lake | Blackford, IN | 34.2 miles | NE |
| Phillips Lake | Delaware, IN | 34.5 miles | NE |
| Wagon Wheel Lake | Marion, IN | 34.8 miles | SW |
| Lake Marion | Grant, IN | 35.1 miles | NE |
| Dollar Lake | Grant, IN | 35.2 miles | NE |
| Burlington Lake | Delaware, IN | 36.2 miles | SE |
| Le-An-Wa Lake | Marion, IN | 37.3 miles | SW |
| Shannon Lake | Marion, IN | 38.2 miles | SW |
| Hamilton Twin Lake | Hancock, IN | 38.3 miles | SE |
| Lake Pleasant | Shelby, IN | 41 miles | SE |
| Lost Lake | Wells, IN | 45.5 miles | NE |
| Morrison Lake | Montgomery, IN | 46.3 miles | SW |
| Saint Mary-of-the-Woods Lake | Morgan, IN | 46.8 miles | SW |
| Lake Blue Water | Blackford, IN | 47.8 miles | NE |
| Lake Cicott | Cass, IN | 49.1 miles | NW |
| Scout Lake | Wayne, IN | 49.4 miles | SE |
| Hi-Way Springs | Wayne, IN | 50.4 miles | SE |
| Osborne Lakes | Wayne, IN | 51.5 miles | SE |
| Mullendore Pond | Johnson, IN | 52.2 miles | SW |
| Hadley Lake | Tippecanoe, IN | 53.2 miles | NW |
| Fletcher Lake | Fulton, IN | 53.6 miles | NW |
| South Mud Lake | Fulton, IN | 54.4 miles | NW |
| Nyona Lake | Fulton, IN | 55.3 miles | NW |
| Bell Lake | Johnson, IN | 55.7 miles | SW |
| McColley Lake | Wabash, IN | 56 miles | NE |
| Round Lake | Wabash, IN | 56 miles | NE |
| Dailey Lake | Johnson, IN | 56.3 miles | SE |
| Mud Lake | Wabash, IN | 56.5 miles | NE |
| Long Lake | Wabash, IN | 56.7 miles | NE |
| Spring Lake | Morgan, IN | 56.7 miles | SW |
| Gaerte Lake | Miami, IN | 56.8 miles | NE |
| H Lake | Johnson, IN | 57.2 miles | SW |
| I Lake | Johnson, IN | 57.2 miles | SW |
| Keesey Lake | Fulton, IN | 57.2 miles | NW |
| Big Blue Lake | Huntington, IN | 57.2 miles | NE |
| Stinson Lake | Fulton, IN | 57.2 miles | NW |
| O'Brien Lake | Fulton, IN | 57.4 miles | NW |
| Donald Lake | Johnson, IN | 57.4 miles | SW |
| Landis Lake | Fulton, IN | 57.4 miles | NE |
|