| Lake Holiday | Montgomery, IN | 2.7 miles | SE |
| Shades Pond | Montgomery, IN | 3.6 miles | SW |
| Sugar Mill Lake | Fountain, IN | 5.1 miles | NW |
| Sportsmans Club Lake | Montgomery, IN | 6 miles | NE |
| Lake Waveland | Montgomery, IN | 6.8 miles | SW |
| Terre Haute Boys Club Lake | Parke, IN | 7.1 miles | SW |
| South Hemlock Lake | Fountain, IN | 7.1 miles | NW |
| North Hemlock Lake | Fountain, IN | 7.4 miles | NW |
| Hemlock Lakes | Fountain, IN | 7.4 miles | NW |
| Painter Lake | Fountain, IN | 9.3 miles | SW |
| Lake Holiday Hide-away | Fountain, IN | 14.7 miles | NW |
| Lakeview Estates Lake | Parke, IN | 16.8 miles | SW |
| Pennington Lake | Montgomery, IN | 17 miles | NE |
| Van Bibber Lake | Putnam, IN | 17.8 miles | SE |
| Cecil M Harden Lake | Parke, IN | 17.8 miles | SW |
| Glenn Flint Lake | Putnam, IN | 17.9 miles | SE |
| Coffing Brothers Lake | Fountain, IN | 19.7 miles | NW |
| Shell Lake | Vermillion, IN | 20.6 miles | SW |
| Rocky Fork Lake | Parke, IN | 20.8 miles | SW |
| Baire Lake | Putnam, IN | 22 miles | SE |
| Shawnee Lake | Fountain, IN | 23.2 miles | NW |
| Case Lake | Parke, IN | 23.5 miles | SW |
| Elmer Martens Lake | Putnam, IN | 23.7 miles | SE |
| Heritage Lake | Putnam, IN | 23.9 miles | SE |
| Oakalla Lake | Putnam, IN | 24.1 miles | SE |
| Albin Pond | Putnam, IN | 24.1 miles | SE |
| Norman Lake | Boone, IN | 24.5 miles | NE |
| Chew Lake | Vermillion, IN | 24.7 miles | SW |
| Riley Lake | Fountain, IN | 24.8 miles | NW |
| Banks Lake | Putnam, IN | 24.9 miles | SE |
| Thomas Lake | Putnam, IN | 24.9 miles | SE |
| Oxidation Pond | Boone, IN | 24.9 miles | NE |
| Quarry Pond | Putnam, IN | 25 miles | SE |
| Edgewood Lake | Putnam, IN | 26.4 miles | SE |
| Desmond Able Lake | Warren, IN | 26.7 miles | NW |
| Bowles Lake | Clay, IN | 28.1 miles | SW |
| Sunset Lake | Hendricks, IN | 29 miles | SE |
| Davis Pond | Warren, IN | 29.1 miles | NW |
| Rutan Farms Lake | Tippecanoe, IN | 29.5 miles | NE |
| Stout Lake | Hendricks, IN | 29.6 miles | SE |
| Dogwood Springs Lake | Putnam, IN | 30.7 miles | SE |
| Westville Lake | Vermilion, IL | 31.1 miles | NW |
| Danville Conservation Club Lake | Hendricks, IN | 31.3 miles | SE |
| Greyhound Lake | Putnam, IN | 31.5 miles | SE |
| Morey Lake | Vigo, IN | 31.5 miles | SW |
| Water Works Lake | Clay, IN | 31.8 miles | SW |
| Risslers Lake | Clay, IN | 32.1 miles | SW |
| Beck Lake | Hendricks, IN | 32.2 miles | SE |
| Georgetown Reservoir | Vermilion, IL | 32.6 miles | SW |
| Donahue Lake | Hendricks, IN | 32.7 miles | SE |
|