| Pennington Lake | Montgomery, IN | 6 miles | NW |
| Norman Lake | Boone, IN | 6.3 miles | NE |
| Oxidation Pond | Boone, IN | 10 miles | NE |
| Stout Lake | Hendricks, IN | 15.9 miles | SE |
| Donahue Lake | Hendricks, IN | 16.8 miles | SE |
| Pins Way Lake | Hendricks, IN | 16.8 miles | SE |
| Danville Conservation Club Lake | Hendricks, IN | 17.3 miles | SE |
| Elrod Lake | Boone, IN | 17.4 miles | SE |
| Elmer Martens Lake | Putnam, IN | 17.7 miles | SW |
| Forest Lake | Hendricks, IN | 17.8 miles | SE |
| Jeto Lake | Hendricks, IN | 17.8 miles | SE |
| Ledgewood Lake | Hendricks, IN | 17.9 miles | SE |
| Sportsmans Club Lake | Montgomery, IN | 17.9 miles | NW |
| Indianhead Lake | Hendricks, IN | 18 miles | SE |
| Holliday Lake | Boone, IN | 18.1 miles | SE |
| Manor Lake | Hendricks, IN | 18.2 miles | SE |
| Penn Lake | Hendricks, IN | 18.4 miles | SE |
| Wurster Lake | Boone, IN | 18.7 miles | NE |
| Lake Holiday | Montgomery, IN | 19.1 miles | SW |
| Traders Point Lake | Hendricks, IN | 19.4 miles | SE |
| Lake View | Hendricks, IN | 19.6 miles | SE |
| Baire Lake | Putnam, IN | 19.6 miles | SW |
| Eagle Lake | Boone, IN | 19.8 miles | SE |
| Beck Lake | Hendricks, IN | 19.8 miles | SE |
| Heritage Lake | Putnam, IN | 20.1 miles | SW |
| Forest Lake | Hendricks, IN | 20.2 miles | SE |
| Eagle Creek Reservoir | Marion, IN | 20.7 miles | SE |
| Lake Ullswater | Hamilton, IN | 21.5 miles | SE |
| Lake Windemere | Hamilton, IN | 21.7 miles | SE |
| Banks Lake | Putnam, IN | 21.8 miles | SW |
| Rutan Farms Lake | Tippecanoe, IN | 22.6 miles | NW |
| Sunset Lake | Hendricks, IN | 23.4 miles | SW |
| Klondike Pond | Hendricks, IN | 23.8 miles | SE |
| West Lake | Marion, IN | 24.3 miles | SE |
| Shades Pond | Montgomery, IN | 24.4 miles | SW |
| Van Bibber Lake | Putnam, IN | 24.9 miles | SW |
| Little Lake | Clinton, IN | 25.5 miles | NE |
| Toms Lake | Marion, IN | 25.6 miles | SE |
| Lake Waveland | Montgomery, IN | 25.9 miles | SW |
| Glenn Flint Lake | Putnam, IN | 25.9 miles | SW |
| Sugar Mill Lake | Fountain, IN | 26 miles | NW |
| Albin Pond | Putnam, IN | 26.2 miles | SW |
| Edgewood Lake | Putnam, IN | 26.6 miles | SW |
| Lake Woodland | Hamilton, IN | 27.5 miles | SE |
| Woodland Addition Lake | Hamilton, IN | 27.5 miles | SE |
| Quarry Pond | Putnam, IN | 27.5 miles | SW |
| Echo Lake | Morgan, IN | 28 miles | SE |
| Terre Haute Boys Club Lake | Parke, IN | 28.1 miles | SW |
| Bray Lake | Morgan, IN | 28.6 miles | SE |
| South Hemlock Lake | Fountain, IN | 28.8 miles | SW |
|